Quick Reads: The Clash, Cheat, The Villains of Hackney and the Price of Honesty

by Chris Harris

In 1970s Hackney, a young father struggles to support his family while working in a pub riddled with corruption. Surrounded by thieves, he clings to his principles until desperation presents an extraordinary opportunity. With £25,000 within reach, he must decide whether honesty is a virtue he can still afford.

Part three of my reinvention of every song on the iconic The Clash by The Clash classic album. Cheat.

An illustrated interior of a vintage kitchen and living area, featuring a wooden table, chairs, a couch, and a window with a view of rooftops. The text overlays read 'Short Stories: The Clash' and 'Cheat: The Villains of Hackney and the Price of Honesty.'

The Villiers pub in Hackney had shifted downmarket. Arthur Pritchard, the new landlord, blamed the decline on the Labour government, the three-day week, and ‘people just not being the same as they used to be.’

It was a huge Victorian pub on the corner of the High Street. Think of the Old Vic in EastEnders, but much bigger and without the crummy actors. It was very much a working-class pub. Quite rowdy at weekends. It was generally always packed, especially at weekends, despite the decline. It still had a brilliant, old-fashioned atmosphere; one of the last pubs in London where you would hear someone tinkle the ivories at night.

His father, Derek, had previously run the pub with military precision and, because of its size and success, made a very good, honest living. He was regarded as a pillar of the local community, always donating, helping local charities and people down on their luck, especially those of whom his alcohol had contributed to their downfall.

Everyone expected Arthur to get involved from when he was a lad, and eventually take over the pub. But Arthur had lazier ideas than long shifts. He was initially swallowed by petty crime instead, which eventually evolved into gambling rackets and money laundering. As a result, he had a slightly subdued relationship with his father, whom he doted on. Likewise, his father, though disappointed with Arthur’s choices, he had always turned a blind eye to his son’s criminal activities.

After Derek’s death, the pub quickly earned the nickname The Villains. Arthur, now in his late forties, swore it was his solemn duty to keep the pub going in his father’s memory and decided to move into the substantial two-floor flat above, where he carried on his illicit activities. He was rarely seen during the day, which was occasionally punctuated by dodgy, roguish-looking people turning up in brand-new Jaguars, slicked-back hair, for various dodgy deals.

The clandestine activity and the owner’s absence freed up all the staff downstairs to steal enormous amounts of money from the till. He knew they were doing it, but he valued one thing about his staff: he knew they were nicking from him; they knew that he was a crook and up to all sorts, so everybody simply kept schtum. A settlement of sorts.

The pub effectively became his headquarters. Most evenings, he would sit upstairs in a smoke-filled room playing poker with four or five old criminal acquaintances at a time, and an entourage of sluts. Whisky flowed, large sums of cash changed hands, and occasional bouts of violence broke out in the seedy world of upstairs at the Villains. Nobody else quite knew what went on, and Derek made sure everyone knew that was for the best.

Mark and Cheryl had met when they were 15. Both were from the suburbs and from stereotypical commuter belt families. Their fathers worked in the city, and their mothers ran the home. The families were both devout Christians. They were studious teenagers, destined to be the first in their respective families to go to university.

But lust got the better of Mark and Cheryl, and when they were 18, they said hello to little Oliver. The new university stage of their lives, which they had both just started, came careering down. Their parents insisted they did the right thing, which neither of them had a problem with, being Christians, in love, and knew they should pay penance for their wrongdoing.

Cheryl moved in with Mark’s family, but it was a hellish arrangement; his parents solely blamed her for their predicament, which made everything deeply unpleasant within the house very quickly. Cheryl’s parents wouldn’t let Mark into their house, having destroyed their precious daughter, so they had to find a tiny flat together in Hackney.

It was above a shop, to be precise, in the attic rooms. The roof leaked, and the wallpaper peeled. Everything was completely antiquated and grotty. A small gas hob, a bathroom with no hot water; they had to boil a kettle, death-trap foam everywhere, bare floorboards and Formica surfaces everywhere, giving it an institutional feel.

But importantly, they loved each other immensely, and Oliver. So much so that within another 18 months, young Benjamin popped forth as well. It was a happy little flat. Cheryl took in sewing work, and Mark worked in a hardware shop. He actually enjoyed it because he was put in charge of making sure everything was stocked up and ordered. It was engrossing work, though badly paid. But it kept the coins feeding the meter and kept them and their young family safe. But only just, and when the sewing work was sparse, they really struggled as they had budgeted money to put away for Mark to eventually go to university, so they could eventually claw their way out of poverty.

To aid this ambition, he took on the mantle of bar assistant at the Villiers on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday nights. He was a popular member of staff; the others had no responsibilities, so they pitied him as the head of a struggling young family, desperately saving any money he could while they robbed the tills.

He got to hear the folklore, all the stories about Arthur running the pub in its heyday. Now overseen by Shirley, or “Shirl the Girl”, as Arthur would call her. She had worked under Derek for 20 years, cleaning, doing some bar work and, after his demise, more hands-on, helping with the tills and cashing up. The rumour was she worked under both of them in an intimate sense as well; she was therefore well and truly part of the furniture and, for Arthur’s convenience, had become the de facto landlady, though, as she readily admitted, a very poor one.

Arthur saw the money they stole as hush money, and Shirl the Girl saw it the same way. Mark fell into an ecosystem of criminality. But he enjoyed working there, enjoyed bantering with the customers. As much as he loved Cheryl, Oliver and Ben, it was nice to get away from the sometimes purgatory of his existence. But he steadfastly refused to get involved with the other staff in procuring the illicit coins and notes.

It was tough watching the scallywags, all of whom he was very fond of, with no commitments, probably get twice the money he did, while he had a family to bring up and lived in relative poverty. But he was young and planning for the sort of future his colleagues could only dream of, even if that dream seemed unachievable in his circumstances.

Pubs were all cleared out by 11:30 in those days, and with Shirl the Girl normally leaving by nine o’clock, Arthur, generally pissed by then, would stagger down to pick the takings up at 11:40. He always made a big deal of this, what a fag it was, although essentially, it was the only activity he invested in towards the running of his pub.

Mark’s work colleagues were all slightly older than him, 25 to 30, and keen for him to join in the nightly raids.

“Come on, Mark, take some. We’ll nick it for you. There’s no reason to play fair; he’s a crook himself and completely minted. He won’t miss it.”

“No, no, no, I can’t. It’s against my values,” he’d reply.

“You won’t get anywhere in life if you don’t cheat when you get the chance.”

He’d always smile as they laughed about Mark’s values and why such a lovely guy wouldn’t use the money to put his family first.

“Come off it, Mark. It’s just an arrangement. Arthur knows it goes on. He doesn’t care.”

But he was resolute.

He had been working for a couple of months when a new gang started drinking in the pub. All were supposedly in their late teens, though many were underage. They were part of this new punk-rock trend. They were silly, messy, and noisy, but, in fairness, polite. There was already a big existing grouping of people in there in their thirties and forties, gnarly, working-class blokes, some with their fishwives, all with dead-end jobs and nothing to look forward to in life, except for going to The Villains as many evenings as they could afford and on a good Friday or Saturday end up in a brawl.

The new ‘scruffy little gobshites’ immediately looked like the perfect target for some macho insecurity. They resented the yobbish and loud behaviour and the rags the punks dressed in, but deeper down their youth and joie de vivre. It quickly evolved into the punks in the saloon bar, a huge saloon bar where they often had live music, and the old hands in the lounge bar.

Another reason Arthur’s son kept this scoundrel staff on was because Shirl the Girl couldn’t praise the staff enough for how they’d kept a potential pub civil war from ever boiling over and the ‘filth’ from sniffing around. The staff took the praise as carte blanche to steal even more money from the till, to the point that one night Shirl the Girl had to say, “You do know I know what you get up to in here, and you’re pushing it too far.”

This left the staff feeling despondent. They felt the contract, the immoral contract they had with Derek, had been broken, and with that, there was no point in trying to keep the house in order. As such, Mark stepped up. You would never have thought the quiet, reflective and gentle Mark would have the confidence or social skills to negotiate such matters, but it is amazing how streetwise his personal circumstances and a couple of months in a rough pub could improve that. On Friday and Saturday nights, he took on the mantle of policing the two factions; the others had his back, but only when necessary.

Tensions eventually boiled over, and one Friday night it all kicked off. Stools, glasses, fists, and limbs began raining down everywhere. Mark jumped over the bar to the epicentre and quickly put his body on the line, and the other staff followed suit, quickly containing the situation. Whoever Derek’s cronies were upstairs could be seen fleeing, knowing the police would turn up. Such was the nastiness of the violence, that within ten minutes, three panda cars and an ambulance were outside. One of the punks had received the attentions of a bottle and had a deep cut to his forehead.

They began mopping up the operation, and an ambulance took a couple of the worst affected away.

Arthur, with his entertainment for the night deserting him, came downstairs to survey the wreckage. The fight had been near closing time, so they decided to finish the evening’s trading prematurely. He realised he’d let it go too far, and he decided to knock some sense into the place. On Shirl the Girl’s recommendation, he promoted Mark to bar manager. It didn’t put her nose out. She was delighted someone else was going to take more responsibility, even though it was just for weekends.

“You’ll have to do the till, Mark. I know what goes on down there, but I won’t hold it against the staff. Okay? Just don’t let them take it too far.” That was all Arthur ever really said to him during the promotion process.

Mark said replied, “Why don’t we just give them a big pay rise and tell them to stop nicking?” It felt like a surreal conversation, but the Villains was a surreal world.

“Ah, not a bad idea, lad. I’ll think on that.” Mark knew he wouldn’t.

Having someone more responsible in charge now meant that at weekends Arthur didn’t have to come down and pick up the takings and could further ensconce himself in his den of iniquity. There was no system for money or its accounting, which suited him fine, as his, shall we say, slightly dodgy accountants would come in and falsify everything to show it making a legal profit, letting him also launder money from his other activities. The upshot being all Mark had to do was put the takings in the till.

It had been a generally cold and wet winter, interspersed with some grim freezing spells. Inside the flat, it had been tough, and all the fifty-pence pieces in the meter were soon drunk up by the lack of any insulation and the need to keep it warm for the toddlers.

“How are we ever going to get out of here?” Cheryl said to him. “Do you think your parents might have us back? This is getting chronic.” When Oliver caught a really bad cold, he began to feel the pressure.

He enjoyed his enhanced role at the Villains and his job at the hardware shop, but he was beginning to realise he’d fallen into a rut. Sure, it was nice having jobs where you were slightly above your work colleagues, but at the end of the day, they were still very badly paid jobs, and as lovely as it was for Cheryl to spend her life with the children, it was in the flat, as she began to spend more of her days at her parents’ house.

He’d begun to get into the habit of staying behind for a few pints on weekends as his personal dilemmas and new work responsibilities began to overwhelm him. He lied to Cheryl, “Oh, I have to. They’ve got me doing all the cashing up and stuff. Sorry, it’s taking me ages to get used to it, because there’s always such a mess from the other four days. But he is paying me more.” Except he wasn’t. Mark was ‘unofficially’ paying himself more.

He was only half-inching a few quid at the weekend, and he justified it by spending it on beer behind the bar, so it wasn’t really nicking; besides, he had introduced efficiencies that meant there was a lot less waste. His moral conscience was fine. He was then given a minor pay rise to recognise his extra duties and honesty, which helped a little at home, and it was nice to socialise with his colleagues after closing, who were now good friends.

Relations between the two factions in the pub had calmed. Some of the ringleaders on each side had been banned, and threats of further action had settled behaviour within the pub, although unpleasantness still flared up outside at closing time. Mark and the staff had warned told them all to take it outside rather than inside.

But a large group of men, all full of strong beer on the weekend, can only keep up good behaviour for so long before it all kicks off again. This time, on a Saturday night, far worse than before, with one of the punters actually stabbed. Again, the police turned up. The pub was cleared out. This was about ten o’clock, and this time, such was the severity of the violence, Arthur was forced to come down and go through the uncomfortable process of dealing with the police, all of whom knew he was a bad ‘un.

He put a twenty-pound note down on the till when he went upstairs. “Have yourself some drinks, guys. You’ve done brilliantly. Well done.” But this was different; it was obvious from the length of time he had spent speaking to the police and the conversations Mark had earwigged that the blind eye someone in the force had been bribed with to keep the prying eyes of authority out of the Villains, was only going to work if it kept off the police radar with weekend fighting. It looked like change was afoot, a new broom, Arthur had told the police. Maybe the twenty pounds was a buttering up before he got professionals in to run the place.

With adrenaline still pumping, the staff laid into some beers. By one o’clock, he felt guilty as he sank into his fourth pint, absolving himself of his husband and fatherly duties. He knew when he got in, he’d reek of alcohol and would be going to the toilet all the time. And he knew Cheryl would know what a bloody disappointment he was.

He could feel himself sinking to the level of the others who worked there. Never as bad as them, because at the end of the day, he desperately needed the money, and took a fraction of what they did. Besides, Shirl the Girl had begun telling him how pleased they were that the accounts were starting to look rosier.

He was already in the shit with Cheryl, so he reasoned he might as well stay on, and by two o’clock, he’d finished his sixth pint and told everyone they’d have to go. He took the money up to the safe, where inside, counting it there and then, was twenty-five thousand pounds in five- and ten-pound notes, neatly trussed together.

It was now or never; he could feel the job about to go. This was the only time in his life he could transform their lives with one action. It was all so wrong, but so was how they lived. He was drunk, he’d never have dreamt of taking the money otherwise

Cheryl was beginning to tire of the late homecoming and the stench of beer. She didn’t begrudge him having a couple; after all, he worked so hard, but it had gone from an hour of Friday and Saturday night to two hours, three nights a week. It was the excuses that hurt her the most, the breaking of trust and how her parents were begging her to leave him and move home.

She explained all of this to him as they sat through the entire Saturday night, drinking tea around the kitchen table, with £25,000 between them, a glittering prize or a poisoned chalice? Crime, morality, belief, integrity, religion, the shithole they lived in, and the rut they were in were the fat they chewed over through the night.

By the time Arthur and Shirl the Girl called round to ‘ask’ where the money was, the four of them were halfway to Devon by train. They had borrowed her parents’ car to remove clothes and precious things and left everything else. Imminently, they would be homeowners without a mortgage; a two-bedroom semi would be £11,000, and both could now afford university. A new life beckoned, but one where they would always have to watch their backs. Around the kitchen table that night, the deal with the devil was that cheats can prosper; they would never be comfortable with it, but with a young family, any real hope of the bright future they dreamed of simply looked impossible, devoured by the reality of dead-end jobs and persistent penury.

Do cheats prosper?, Only time will tell, but some do. Well, that was the hope, anyway.