Dungeness and the Fascinating Hidden Costs of Nuclear Power

by Chris Harris

Walking around Dungeness nuclear power station, I was astonished to discover hundreds of people still working at a site that stopped generating electricity years ago. What followed was a fascinating investigation into the extraordinary costs, decades of dismantling and radioactive waste management. Nuclear power produces enormous amounts of electricity, but what happens when the lights finally go out?

Dungeness nuclear power station with construction cranes, a coastal landscape, and the title “Dungeness and the Fascinating Hidden Costs of Nuclear Power.”

Walking around Dungeness power station yesterday, I counted roughly 200 cars in the staff car park. The cranes were whizzing about and there was clearly plenty going on. Which seemed odd for somewhere that no longer produces electricity. I had rather assumed that once a power station closed, most people went home and someone came along to knock it down. Sure, not that simplistic, the residue of waste needs to disposed off.

Apparently, I had underestimated the job. By about 90 years. There are actually two power stations at Dungeness. The older one, Dungeness A, began generating electricity in 1965 and closed as planned at the end of 2006, after roughly four decades of service. Dungeness B started generating in 1983, last produced electricity in 2018 and was finally declared permanently closed in June 2021.

B had been expected to carry on until around 2028, but a maintenance shutdown uncovered problems. Steam pipework and corrosion issues were dealt with, only for further investigations to reveal that some irreplaceable components inside the boilers had deteriorated faster than expected. There were also concerns involving parts of the fuel assemblies. After spending nearly three years out of action, EDF decided against restarting it. That was the end of making electricity, taking the place apart is another matter altogether.

EDF’s published figures list around 550 full-time employees and more than 200 full-time contract partners at B alone. Roughly 750 people associated with a power station that has not generated electricity since 2018. There is a separate workforce dealing with A as well. Suddenly, my 200 cars seemed rather less surprising. Going to stay adjacent to the station, I assumed there would maybe be twenty or so contractors. Mind you, it is only hen you walk around it, the actual scale becomes apparent; the place is vast, not just the generators and associated buildings, but the huge office / admin etc blocks.

Just last month, a contract worth up to £190 million was announced for work at Dungeness A. This will remove eight boilers, each weighing around 800 tonnes, along with associated equipment and infrastructure. About 6,400 tonnes of boilers. I occasionally complain about the difficulties of moving a wardrobe. I shall try to retain some perspective.

Four years of preparation preceded this phase. Once finished, it will account for the removal of roughly a third of A’s above-ground structures. So £190 million gets a substantial chunk of the place dismantled, with plenty still to do. Even removing the fuel was quite an operation. That was completed at A in 2012, almost six years after generation stopped. Some 55,000 fuel elements, weighing 610 tonnes, were taken out and dispatched in 332 fuel flasks. Removing the fuel does not, of course, remove all the radioactive material left in the station.

The current plan gives the 2060s as the earliest estimated period for completing A’s planned physical work. Even that is conditional, and there is no settled date in the plan for disposal of all its radioactive waste. A station that generated for about 41 years could therefore spend considerably longer being taken apart.

B offers a choice of timescales that I find even more extraordinary. One proposal would take approximately 40 years from the start of the decommissioning project. The other would take around 90. Under the longer option, much of the surrounding plant would be demolished, while the reactor complex and high-activity waste vault would be enclosed in a secure, weather-tight structure. It would then spend decades under care and maintenance, allowing radioactivity to reduce before the final dismantling.

So there would not be cranes swinging continuously for 90 years. There would, however, be a site needing inspections, upkeep and management long after most of us had ceased to require any of those things. The shorter option would tackle reactor dismantling sooner, without that long pause. It depends on suitable arrangements for disposing of or storing the radioactive waste. Both approaches are still being considered. Neither is a promise that everything will be gone by a particular date.

Naturally, I wanted to know what all this would cost. The government’s published estimate for future decommissioning liabilities across seven advanced gas-cooled reactor stations, including Dungeness B, is about £22.6 billion. Divide that equally and it works out at roughly £3.2 billion per station. That gives some idea of the scale, but it is not Dungeness B’s individual budget, and Dungeness A is a separate bill.

There is another rather sobering figure. In 2022, the National Audit Office reported that B’s unexpectedly early closure was estimated to add between £500 million and £1 billion to its defuelling costs. Additional costs. Before getting anywhere near completing the whole job. But then, how much money did the stations generate while they were working? Surely that needs to be part of the equation.

Between them, A and B produced approximately 262 terawatt-hours of electricity: 120 from A and 142 from B. That is 262 billion kilowatt-hours. Whatever one thinks about nuclear power, that is a considerable amount of electricity. Putting a price on it is less straightforward. There is no neat public total showing everything earned by each station throughout its life. As an illustration, value all that electricity at an assumed £50 per megawatt-hour and it comes to £13.1 billion: £6 billion for A and £7.1 billion for B. Use £60 instead and the combined value rises to approximately £15.7 billion.

That does not mean EDF made £15 billion in profit. These are illustrative values for the electricity, rather than records of what customers actually paid. Prices varied over the decades, and construction, fuel, maintenance, wages and financing all cost money. EDF only acquired B in 2009, through its purchase of British Energy, so much of its generating history belonged to earlier owners. Nor can we say that the two stations earned £15 billion and will cost £3 billion to clear away. The first figure values both stations’ output at an assumed price. The second is an average liability across a different group of stations. They do not describe the same thing, however tempting the subtraction might be.

There were benefits beyond selling electricity. EDF estimates that B contributed more than £1 billion to Kent’s economy and avoided almost 50 million tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions compared with equivalent gas-fired generation. The jobs, the electricity and the lower emissions all deserve their place in the calculation.

As does the question of who pays when it is over. A is part of the publicly funded Nuclear Decommissioning Authority estate. B is due to transfer to the authority after EDF removes its fuel. Relevant cleanup costs are funded through the Nuclear Liabilities Fund, established under the British Energy privatisation arrangements in 1996. EDF makes contractual contributions, and the fund also relies on its investments. If it cannot meet the covered liabilities, the government guarantees them. Which means that, ultimately, the taxpayer stands behind the arrangement, well that’s not a first!

Make both our days by buying a copy of my book!

Something About England: Amazon.co.uk: Harris, Mr Christopher, Turner, Louise: 9798181129351: Books

Welcome to Denham, a fictitious Sussex village where behind respectable doors, well-tended gardens and familiar faces, things have a habit of going badly wrong.

Obsession, ambition, deception, jealousy and petty rivalry run through this collection of tragi-comical and satirical short stories. From poltergeists and lottery winners to cricket club feuds and environmental disasters, ordinary people embark on discovering just how quickly an ordinary life can unravel into an extraordinary mess.

Darkly funny, occasionally poignant and populated by characters who are rarely quite what they seem, these stories explore the peculiarities of Middle England, and the uncomfortable territory between respectability and ruin.